Crime in Our Communities | Explainer
Read our weekly court lists long enough and you'll hit a phrase that sounds like a contradiction.
"Dismissed after deferral."
Year to date, the Midcoast lists we track show 33 charges ending that way (Week 4). That's only what Lincoln County's lists spell out. Knox and Waldo lists usually just say "dismissed," so the real number is likely higher.
So what is a deferred disposition? And how does a guilty plea end in a dismissal?
The short version
A deferred disposition is a deal with conditions.
-
The person pleads guilty.
-
The judge puts off sentencing to a set date and sets requirements for the time in between.
-
At the end, if the person met the requirements, they get the outcome agreed to up front. That can be a lighter sentence, or the guilty plea can be withdrawn and the charge dismissed.
-
If they didn't, the judge can sentence them on the crime they pleaded guilty to.
It's all in Maine's criminal code, 17-A M.R.S. §§1901 to 1904.
Who can get one
Under §1901, a person is eligible if they:
- pleaded guilty to a Class C, D or E crime, or a Class B drug crime, and
- consent in writing to the deferred disposition.
For scale, the maximum prison terms are 5 years for Class C, less than one year for Class D and 6 months for Class E (§1604). Class B carries up to 10 years. Other Class B crimes, and Class A crimes, the most serious, aren't eligible.
What happens during the deferment
Under §1902, after the guilty plea the court can set requirements it considers "reasonable and appropriate to assist the person to lead a law-abiding life."
- One requirement is mandatory: stay out of criminal trouble.
- The court may add others, including days in a county sheriff's program that can involve overnight housing, community service and education.
- The court may charge a supervision fee of up to $50 a month, after considering what the person can afford.
- The requirements usually start right away.
Either side, or the judge, can ask to change the requirements. If the person can't meet one, it's on them to ask the court for a change.
Two details matter more than they sound:
- No conviction yet. The person is considered convicted only when a sentence is imposed. Until then, they're on pre-conviction bail.
- Drugs. For possession of what Maine calls "schedule W" drugs, the law says a deferred disposition is a preferred outcome.
How it ends
Under §1903, the person comes back to court when the deferment is over.
If they met the requirements, the judge imposes the sentence that was agreed to in writing when sentencing was put off. Unless the prosecutor moves to let the person withdraw the guilty plea. If the person doesn't object, the judge has to allow it. Then the prosecutor must dismiss the charge with prejudice, which means it can't be brought again.
The prosecutor and the person can also agree in writing to withdraw the plea without a hearing. Same result: dismissed with prejudice.
That's what "dismissed after deferral" means on our lists.
Notice what the law does not say. Finishing the conditions doesn't automatically erase the charge. The deal can call for a reduced sentence instead. Whether it ends in a dismissal depends on what was agreed at the start and on the prosecutor's motion at the end.
If they didn't meet the requirements, the prosecutor can ask the court to end the deferment early. If the prosecutor proves the person "inexcusably failed" to comply, the judge can keep the deferment going, change the conditions, add new ones, or end it and impose a sentence.
The person gets a hearing, a chance to cross-examine witnesses and present evidence, and a lawyer if they can't afford one. Missing a supervision payment isn't enough on its own if the person couldn't pay despite a good-faith effort.
Appeals are narrow. Under §1904, a person sentenced after a failed deferral can ask the Law Court to hear an appeal, but not as of right.
What it does to a record
Two different records, two different answers.
- The court case. The court's own case record is separate, and court rules decide what's public. Here's how to look up a Maine court case.
- Criminal history. Under Maine law, a charge "dismissed by a court with prejudice" is confidential criminal history record information (16 M.R.S. §703). The State Bureau of Identification's public check reports convictions and recent pending cases (SBI).
So a completed deferral that ends in dismissal generally won't appear on a public criminal history check. A failed one ends in a sentence, which is a conviction.
Old numbers, same idea
If you're reading older court documents or news stories, you may see deferred disposition cited as 17-A M.R.S. §1348 and the sections after it. Those were repealed when Maine reorganized its sentencing laws in 2019 (PL 2019, c. 113). The rules now live in §§1901 to 1904.
Why it matters
A deferral can be a real second chance. Someone fixes what led them to court, and a charge doesn't follow them for life.
It can also make an outcome hard to see. When a list just says "dismissed," you can't tell whether a case fell apart, a victim stepped back, or someone did a year of hard work to earn it. We've written about what "dismissed" can mean and why the lists rarely say.
Both things can be true in the same courthouse in the same week. The way to tell them apart is to ask.
At the end, a dismissal only happens if the prosecutor moves for it. Here's how a Maine DA decides whether to charge and what the DA's office actually does.
Ask yourself
- When a list says "dismissed after deferral," what would you want to know? The conditions? How long it took? Whether a victim was heard?
- Should court lists say when a deferral failed, not just when it worked?
- For which kinds of cases do you think a second chance makes the most sense? Where would you draw the line?
See every week of Crime in Our Communities.
Sources: Maine Revised Statutes, 17-A M.R.S. §1901, §1902, §1903, §1904, §1604, former §1348; 16 M.R.S. §703. Maine State Police, State Bureau of Identification. Talk to Your Neighbors, Midcoast Court Outcomes, Week 4.



