Brody Sawyer, 17, was on foot on Friendship Road in Waldoboro on Wednesday afternoon. A pickup truck veered right and hit him. The driver didn't stop.
He died at the hospital in Damariscotta. Police stopped the truck a short time later and arrested the driver, a 53-year-old Waldoboro man. He's charged with manslaughter, OUI-drugs resulting in death, and leaving the scene of a fatal crash. He's being held without bail, and his first court appearance is Friday.
Take a beat
By Thursday afternoon, the Maine Wire had posted an "EXCLUSIVE" video. The caption says Brody was "tragically killed in a hit-and-run by an intoxicated driver outside a known drug house," and adds: "We spoke with the driver's niece, who had been begging police and local authorities to do something about the drug house in the days before the tragedy. They didn't, and now a young child is dead."
I sent them a message. Short version… take a beat. A family is grieving. Talk to the Waldoboro PD before deciding who's to blame.
Check the caption against the record. "Intoxicated" is written as a finding. Right now it's a charge. And the "known drug house" is described in the video as on Reef Road, north of the village. The crash was on Friendship Road, south of the village, about three and a half miles away at the closest point. Maybe the driver came from that house. Nobody official has said so.
And "They didn't" is a verdict: the caption blames police and local authorities for not acting on the house before the crash, even though the video includes no police response.
The Maine Wire was founded by the Maine Policy Institute and relaunched in 2023 under editor Steve Robinson. My quarrel is with the framing, not the people. A villain in the caption gets clicks. It also drives a wedge, right when this family needs a town standing together.
Be fair to the niece
The woman in the video is grieving too, and she's angry. She says she called local police, the county, State Police, drug agents, Adult Protective Services and the DA's office, for three days straight, and six months ago. She says she saw a deal, offered photos and video, and was turned away.
That deserves a real answer. Out loud, from the people she called.
It's also one relative's account, not a finding. Both are true. Hold both.
Go talk to the PD
When I moved here, I'd have watched a video like this and thought: drug house, police problem. Then I started going to town meetings and talking to the Waldoboro PD.
What they told me about was frustration with catch and release. Officers are still doing the paperwork when the person they arrested walks out after paying $60. Or nothing at all.
The $60 isn't bail. It's a fee. The bail commissioner who comes to the jail can charge up to $60 (15 M.R.S. §1023). Bail itself is often just a promise to appear, and if someone can't pay the fee, the law says they "must nonetheless be released."
For low-level charges, cash bail is mostly off the table. A 2021 law, LD 1703, bars cash bail when the most serious charge is Class E, with exceptions like domestic violence, sex offenses and new crimes while on bail. A 2025 bill to change the bail laws died in both chambers. And bail is set by commissioners and judges. Not the police. Not the district attorney.
This driver faces Class A, B and C charges and is being held without bail. A death case doesn't walk out the door on a $60 fee. Where it goes from here isn't up to a bail commissioner. It's up to the prosecutor.
"A misdemeanor not in our presence"
The Maine Wire's own footage shows the limits police work under. In the niece's phone video, an officer tells her: "It's a misdemeanor not in our presence so we can't arrest them… nobody going to jail today."
For most low-level crimes, that's the law. Under 17-A M.R.S. §15, most Class D and E crimes have to happen in front of an officer for a warrantless arrest, with exceptions like domestic violence. The clip doesn't say which offense the officer meant.
Drug crimes are different. Police can arrest on probable cause, even for misdemeanors. Possession is still a crime in Maine. But probable cause is the bar. For a search warrant, Maine courts look at the "totality of the circumstances." One firsthand eyewitness can be enough, but drug warrants are usually built on controlled buys and surveillance. That takes months.
And Waldoboro police do work those cases. In April, a multi-agency search of a home on Reef Road led to six arrests. Whether it was the same house, the record doesn't say. By September, the department reported 84 drug investigations this year. Whether it could have worked this one is the question the niece deserves answered.
What about the DA?
None of those bail rules are on District Attorney Natasha Irving. What happens after the arrest is. Her office decides what to charge, whether to argue for bail or ask a judge to revoke it, which plea deals to offer, who gets a deferral and which cases get dismissed. In other words, whether there are consequences.
Two things can be true at the same time. A person who commits a crime owns that choice. No prosecutor changes that, and if this driver is convicted, it's on him. AND when a prosecutor's track record points consistently toward lenience, it creates an atmosphere where people expect the law to look the other way… until something like Wednesday happens. When consequences come out of the equation, there's far less standing between the next bad choice and the next tragedy.
I don't know if this driver's history includes a dropped charge. The pattern doesn't depend on one case, and we've been watching it.
Our own court tracking. Since January, we've logged how District 6 cases end, from local papers' court lists, excluding OUI and traffic. Of 2,589 closed charges through Nov. 15, 866, a full third, ended in a dismissal, a charge dropped for a plea, or a dismissal after a deferral. Only 31% ended in jail. In drug cases, 102 of 336 charges were dismissed, and 42% were dismissed or got a fully suspended sentence. In violence and domestic violence cases, 283 of 553 (51%) were dismissed, dropped for a plea or deferred. It's a floor, not a full count: Sagadahoc has no public list, and some weeks are missing.
Some dismissals are surely the right call: a victim won't testify, evidence gets thrown out. But in the Knox and Waldo lists, dismissals almost never come with a public reason, so nobody can tell which.
It's the stated approach. When she took office in 2019, Irving told her prosecutors to seek restorative justice in all but the most violent cases, and to offer first-offense OUI drivers under 0.11 a deferral ending in a plea to driving to endanger. That doesn't cover a fatal crash. It does show the posture.
People have noticed. In October 2025, a Lincoln County budget advisory committee recommended giving her office $1; one member called it "a statement being made that we're unhappy with the present district attorney's administration." Irving called it "reckless and irresponsible." In April, Knox County budget committee member Nichole Kalloch said she was tired of seeing "dismissal, dismissal, dismissal" for domestic violence and weapons charges. Irving called that misinformation, and part of Kalloch's complaint was about a homicide the Attorney General handled. The dismissal numbers above are not misinformation.
Then there's the Rockland school-bus case. A 12-year-old was killed by a school bus in November 2025, and a grand jury indicted the driver for manslaughter. In August, Irving's office dismissed it for a civil traffic infraction: 180 hours of community service, a four-year license loss, no jail. Rockland Police Chief Tim Carroll said his investigators had evidence they believed showed "criminal gross negligence," and that "criminal charges were justified."
Her answer: criminal negligence means a "gross deviation" from what a reasonable person would do. Justice William Stokes, a former homicide prosecutor, reviewed the evidence, including video of the driver looking down for about two seconds. She said he told her it couldn't be proven beyond a reasonable doubt and would likely end in a hung jury or acquittal. The boy's parents wanted it over. She also says her office carries about 2,400 active cases and has the second-highest conviction rate in Maine. I haven't been able to verify that rate.
That's a real argument. But a child died, a grand jury indicted, and the result was community service. Add a third of charges ending in dismissal, and you can see why people feel consequences have gone missing.
Why it matters right now. Vehicular manslaughter cases in this district have landed in her office before, so this one likely will too. And by her own public standard, driving drunk or high is "clearly a gross deviation." So let's not burn our energy fighting over a $60 bail fee. Keep our eyes on what her office does with this case, and on the pattern of dropped consequences behind it.
What we can actually do
What I'm asking of neighbors:
- Show up. Select board meetings are where I learned this. Ask what our officers need.
- Report specifics. Dates, times, plates, what you saw. Call Waldoboro PD at 832-4500, or text "MDEA" plus your tip to 847411.
- Use the neighbor tool for a suspected drug house. If neighbors are dealing with a property like the Reef Road house described in the video, or any suspected drug house in Lincoln County, Maine's common-nuisance statute (17 M.R.S. §2741) lets at least seven legal voters of Lincoln County (or the DA or Attorney General) ask Superior Court for an injunction shutting it down. Because it is a civil case, the bar is a preponderance of the evidence rather than a criminal conviction: proving an owner or occupant trafficked or furnished scheduled drugs there twice within three years is enough, and an order runs against the building itself. Under 17 M.R.S. §2743, a tenant using a rental that way also forfeits their lease rights.
- How to start a nuisance petition: Keep a dated log of what you witnessed, any police calls and any convictions or charges tied to the address, and ask the DA or Attorney General first whether they will file (they pay no court filing fee). If seven registered Lincoln County voters file on their own, bring the facts to a Maine civil attorney first—the Maine State Bar Association Lawyer Referral Service charges $35 for a 30-minute consultation—or file in paper at Lincoln County Superior Court, 32 High St., Wiscasset (open Monday–Friday, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.; clerk's office (207) 882-6363). You need a written complaint signed by the seven voters, a Civil Summary Sheet (CV-001) marking "Nuisance" or "General Injunctive Relief," a $5 Summons from the clerk, and the $175 civil filing fee on the Maine Court Fees Schedule (or fee-waiver form CV-067 on the Maine Judicial Branch forms page), followed by formal service on the owner or occupant before the court sets a hearing.
- Wait for the record. Friday is a first appearance, not a verdict.
And here's what I'd like answered:
For the Waldoboro PD: What happened with the niece's calls? What would it have taken to get a warrant?
For DA Irving: Will your office handle this case? If any charge is reduced or dismissed, will you explain why in public? Will you start giving a public reason when your office drops a charge?
For the select board: Does our police department have what it needs to work drug cases that take months?
Brody Sawyer's family lost their son this week. Let's give them a town that stands together first, and asks hard questions second… with the facts in hand.
#TalkToYourNeighbors
Sources
- Lincoln County News, "Teenager Dies in Waldoboro Hit-and-Run," Nov. 19, 2026: https://lcnme.com/369498/currentnews/teenager-dies-in-waldoboro-hit-and-run/
- WMTW, "17-year-old killed in Waldoboro hit-and-run; suspect charged with OUI of drugs," Nov. 19, 2026: https://www.wmtw.com/article/juvenile-killed-in-waldoboro-crash-suspect-in-custody-officials-say/74471827
- WGME, "Man accused of killing teen in Waldoboro hit-and-run," Nov. 19, 2026: https://wgme.com/news/local/waldoboro-man-accused-of-killing-pedestrian-in-deadly-hit-and-run
- Portland Press Herald, "Teen killed in Waldoboro hit-and-run; driver arrested," Nov. 19, 2026: https://www.pressherald.com/2026/11/19/teen-killed-in-waldoboro-hit-and-run-driver-arrested/
- The Maine Wire on X, Nov. 19, 2026: https://x.com/TheMaineWire/status/2123517966667108552
- The Maine Wire vigil-flyer reply naming Brody Sawyer on X, Nov. 19, 2026: https://x.com/TheMaineWire/status/2123518151795130452
- The Maine Wire, "About Us": https://www.themainewire.com/about/
- OpenStreetMap, Reef Road, Waldoboro: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/11454793
- OpenStreetMap, Friendship Road, Waldoboro: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/11453713
- Lincoln County News, "Six Arrested in Waldoboro Following Alleged Kidnapping, Assault," April 25, 2026: https://lcnme.com/335477/homepage/six-arrested-in-waldoboro-following-alleged-kidnapping-assault/
- Lincoln County News, "Waldoboro Police Chief Shares Year-To-Date Response Numbers," Oct. 1, 2026: https://lcnme.com/365525/currentnews/waldoboro-police-chief-shares-year-to-date-response-numbers/
- 15 M.R.S. §1023, bail commissioners and the $60 fee: https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/15/title15sec1023.html
- 15 M.R.S. §1026, release standards and the Class E cash-bail limit: https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/15/title15sec1026.html
- Maine Legislature, LD 1703, "An Act To Amend the Bail Code" (Public Law 2021, chapter 397): https://legislature.maine.gov/LawMakerWeb/summary.asp?LD=1703&SessionID=14
- Maine Legislature, LD 1536, "An Act to Amend the Laws Governing Bail" (2025): https://legislature.maine.gov/LawMakerWeb/summary.asp?LD=1536&SessionID=16
- Sun Journal, "Repeat offenders drive frustration with Maine's bail system," Sept. 14, 2025: https://www.sunjournal.com/2025/09/14/repeat-offenders-drive-frustration-with-maines-bail-system/
- 17-A M.R.S. §15, warrantless arrests: https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/17-A/title17-Asec15.html
- 17-A M.R.S. §1107-A, unlawful possession of scheduled drugs: https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/17-A/title17-Asec1107-A.html
- Portland Press Herald, "Bill to make drug possession for personal use a civil violation fails after Senate vote," July 1, 2021: https://www.pressherald.com/2021/07/01/maine-senate-rejects-bill-that-would-make-drug-possession-for-personal-use-a-civil-violation/
- State v. Perrigo, 640 A.2d 1074 (Me. 1994): https://openjurist.org/640/a2d/1074/state-v-perrigo-1540666
- Maine Drug Enforcement Agency, Tip 411: https://www3.maine.gov/dps/mdea/contact/tip-411
- Town of Waldoboro, Police Department: https://www.waldoboromaine.org/departments/police/index.php
- 17 M.R.S. §2741, common nuisances: https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/17/title17sec2741.html
- 17 M.R.S. §2743, lease forfeiture for common nuisances: https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/17/title17sec2743.html
- Maine Judicial Branch, Lincoln County Superior Court (Wiscasset): https://www.courts.maine.gov/courts/superior/lincoln-sc.html
- Maine Judicial Branch, Civil Summary Sheet (CV-001): https://mjbportal.courts.maine.gov/CourtForms/FormsLists/DownloadForm?strFormNumber=CV-001
- Maine Judicial Branch, Court Forms: https://www.courts.maine.gov/forms/
- Maine Supreme Judicial Court, Revised Court Fees Schedule (JB-05-26): https://courts.maine.gov/adminorders/jb-05-26.pdf
- Maine Judicial Branch, Service of Court Papers: https://www.courts.maine.gov/help/service.html
- Maine State Bar Association, Lawyer Referral Service: https://www.mainebar.org/page/LawyerReferralService
- Talk to Your Neighbors, "Midcoast Court Outcomes, Week 4," Nov. 2026: https://talktoyourneighbors.com/stories/midcoast-court-outcomes-week-4
- Maine Public / Bangor Daily News, "How A New District Attorney Is Shaking Up The Justice System In Midcoast Maine," May 28, 2019: https://www.mainepublic.org/courts-and-crime/2019-05-28/how-a-new-district-attorney-is-shaking-up-the-justice-system-in-midcoast-maine
- Lincoln County News, "Irving Focuses on Expanding Restorative Practices in Third-Term Bid," Oct. 24, 2026: https://lcnme.com/366766/currentnews/irving-focuses-on-expanding-restorative-practices-in-third-term-bid/
- Bangor Daily News, "Midcoast DA, state Senate candidate clash over case dismissals, public safety," April 18, 2026: https://www.bangordailynews.com/2026/04/18/midcoast/midcoast-police-courts/budget-committee-clash-irving-kalloch/
- Bangor Daily News, "Lincoln County officials protest their prosecutor by recommending $1 budget," Oct. 28, 2025: https://www.bangordailynews.com/2025/10/28/politics/state-politics/lincoln-county-protest-local-prosecutor-budget-joam40zk0w/
- Bangor Daily News, "Rockland police say criminal charges justified in death of child hit by school bus," Aug. 5, 2026: https://www.bangordailynews.com/2026/08/05/midcoast/midcoast-police-courts/rockland-police-say-criminal-charges-justified-death-of-child-hit-by-school-bus/
- PenBay Pilot, "District attorney issues statement on plea deal with school bus driver and state in fatal Rockland incident," Aug. 10, 2026: https://www.penbaypilot.com/article/bus-driver-update/273112
- Bangor Daily News, "Prosecutor responds to criticism over plea deal that let bus driver avoid jail time in Rockland boy's death," Aug. 10, 2026: https://www.bangordailynews.com/2026/08/10/midcoast/midcoast-police-courts/rockland-maine-brayden-callahan-death-plea-deal-natasha-irving-statement/
- WGME, "Former Rockland school bus driver who hit, killed 12-year-old will not face jail time," Aug. 11, 2026: https://wgme.com/news/local/former-rockland-school-bus-driver-who-hit-killed-12-year-old-will-not-face-jail-time-maine-civil-violation-manslaughter
- 17-A M.R.S. §35, definition of criminal negligence: https://legislature.maine.gov/statutes/17-A/title17-Asec35.html
- Portland Press Herald, "Maine high court rejects state law requiring blood tests in fatal crashes," Jan. 28, 2020: https://www.pressherald.com/2020/01/28/court-rejects-maine-blood-test-law-but-affirms-trucker-conviction-in-double-fatal/



