September 9, 2016. A fundraiser in New York City. Hillary Clinton is talking about her opponent's voters.
"You know, to just be grossly generalistic, you could put half of Trump's supporters into what I call the basket of deplorables. Right? The racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamaphobic—you name it."
The room laughs and applauds. She also said the other half "feel that the government has let them down," and "those are people we have to understand and empathize with as well" (TIME, Sept. 10, 2016).
October 13, 2024. Donald Trump is on Fox News' "Sunday Morning Futures." Asked whether he expects chaos on Election Day, he says not "from the side that votes for Trump."
"I think the bigger problem is the enemy from within… We have some very bad people. We have some sick people. Radical left lunatics." It "should be very easily handled by, if necessary, by National Guard, or if really necessary, by the military" (CNN, Oct. 13, 2024).
Neither one said everyone on the other side. Read them fairly. But both took fellow Americans and cast them as the thing to fear.
Two candidates. Two parties. Same move.
You don't have to love us. You just have to be more afraid of them.
The thesis
In Part 3, the sorted voter became a safe seat. In Part 4, the sorted, scared voter paid the bills.
This is the last harvest, and the most valuable one. Your loyalty.
I'll say it plainly.
When fear of the other side keeps you on the team, nobody has to earn your vote with results.
That's the retention plan. A business that can't keep customers with a better product keeps them by making the competitor look dangerous. A party can do the same thing with you.
The good news is in the same sentence. A vote that isn't earned can be taken back.
How EXACTLY does that work?
Watch the steps.
Step one: give people a reason to stay that has nothing to do with you. In 2022, Pew asked partisans why they belong to their party. Among Republicans, 78% called the harm done by Democratic policies a major reason. Among Democrats, 68% said the same about Republican policies.
Now the fair part, and it matters. Nearly as many Republicans (76%) cited the good their own party's policies do. Democrats cited their own party's policies at the same 68%. People have real positive reasons, too.
But look at the independents who lean toward a party. Pew found only one reason, of the five it asked about, that a majority of both groups called major: the other party's policies are harmful. That was 57% of Republican leaners and 55% of Democratic leaners (Pew Research Center, Aug. 9, 2022).
For the loosest members of each team, the other team is the glue.
Step two: turn the opponent into a bad person. Disagreeing about policy is normal. Here's what happened to how we see the people.
In 2016, 47% of Republicans and 35% of Democrats said people in the other party were more immoral than other Americans. By 2022, it was 72% of Republicans and 63% of Democrats. Meanwhile, 83% of Democrats called Republicans more closed-minded than other Americans, and 69% of Republicans said that about Democrats (Pew Research Center, Aug. 9, 2022).
Notice the gaps run in different directions on different questions. Republicans lead on one measure. Democrats lead on the other. I'm not going to average them into a tie, and I'm not going to pick the one that flatters my side. Both are high. Both went up.
And here's the mirror. The share of Republicans who called their own party's people more moral than other Americans rose from 51% in 2016 to 63%. Among Democrats, from 38% to 51%.
The other side got worse in our eyes. Our own side got better. In both parties, at the same time.
Step three: get paid in attention for saying so. Researchers at Cambridge and NYU studied 2.7 million Facebook and Twitter posts from U.S. media outlets and members of Congress from both parties. Posts about the other side were shared about twice as often as posts praising one's own side. For members of Congress, each word aimed at the other side was linked to a 65% to 180% increase in sharing. Words about one's own side did little.
"This was the case for both Republican and Democrat-leaning media outlets and politicians on Facebook and Twitter," said Steve Rathje, the study's first author (University of Cambridge, on Rathje, Van Bavel & van der Linden, PNAS, June 2021).
Put the three steps together. The enemy keeps you enrolled. The contempt keeps you from wandering. The algorithm pays the politician for feeding both.
And none of it requires the people you elected to deliver a single thing.
Calling a threat a threat isn't the trick
Let's be careful here, because this is where the argument can go wrong.
Some threats are real. Some policies do harm. Saying so, with evidence, is not fear mongering. It's your job as a citizen, and it's a candidate's job too.
The trick is different. The trick is when the danger of the other side becomes the whole case. When you can't name what your own side has done for you lately…but you can name, in detail, what the other side will do to you.
Ask whether you're hearing about a policy or about a people. A policy can be argued with. A "people" can only be feared.
These surveys don't prove any party manufactured this. And they don't show that contempt caused any particular failure in Congress. The retention plan is my reading of the incentives, not a measured result. But the incentive is sitting right there in the numbers.
Plenty of people already feel it
Here's the thing the retention plan can't hide. People notice.
In that same 2022 survey, 27% of Americans had an unfavorable view of both parties. In 1994, it was 6%. And 39% said this describes them extremely or very well: "I often wish there were more political parties to choose from in this country" (Pew Research Center).
A lot of people are staying put because they're scared of the alternative, not because they're satisfied.
That's not loyalty. That's a hostage situation with yard signs.
The way out isn't surrender
So how do you get out without giving up what you believe?
In 2024, a team of scholars tested 25 different approaches on 32,059 Americans in one large study published in Science. Many of them reduced partisan animosity. The strongest did it by "highlighting relatable sympathetic individuals with different political beliefs" or "emphasizing common identities shared by rival partisans." Correcting wrong ideas about what the other side actually believes helped reduce support for undemocratic practices (Voelkel et al., Science, abstract via PubMed, Oct. 18, 2024).
Be honest about the limits. These were treatments tested in a study, not proof of a lasting, real-world cure. And reducing animosity and protecting democratic norms were separate results, from different treatments.
That's the point. You can keep every conviction you have and still drop the contempt. Meeting a real person on the other side, and remembering what you share, works better than another warning about what they'll do to you.
Which is what this site has been asking you to do all along.
The whole series on one page
Here's where we've been.
Part 1: The lines were here before the labels. Parties didn't invent our divisions. They harvested them.
Part 2: Make the group your whole world. Once your identity comes with a party attached, you're a cheap vote.
Part 3: They pick the voters, then guard the door. Sorted voters become safe seats, and a small primary crowd decides who gets in.
Part 4: They manufacture the emergency…paid for with your card. The sorted, scared group pays the bills.
Part 5: The enemy is the retention plan. And as long as you're afraid of the other side, your loyalty never has to be earned.
Divide the populace. Then divide the voters. And power piles up and stays put.
Both parties have done it. Neither is going to stop on its own. Why would they? It works…as long as we let it.
Your assignment
This series ends with homework, not a hashtag.
One: pick one promise from your own candidate. Not the other side's. Yours. Check it against the public record: the votes, the bills, the results. Did it happen?
Two: decide what would cost that candidate your vote. Say it out loud. If the honest answer is "nothing," you're not a voter anymore. You're a guaranteed number.
Three: ask a neighbor what outcome they want. Not which team they're on. What they want for their kids, their street, their paycheck. You'll probably find more overlap than any fundraising email wants you to know about.
You can disagree with that neighbor about almost everything and still refuse to cast them as your enemy. Respect the person. Confront the idea.
Ask yourself
If my party stopped warning me about the other side tomorrow, what would it have left to tell me?
When was the last time I held my own side to account?
Where it began
In Part 1, we heard George Washington's warning from 1796. One way a party gains influence, he said, is "to misrepresent the opinions and aims of other districts." The jealousies those misrepresentations stir up "tend to render alien to each other those who ought to be bound together by fraternal affection" (Washington's Farewell Address, 1796).
He also gave us the answer. "The name of American, which belongs to you, in your national capacity, must always exalt the just pride of patriotism more than any appellation derived from local discriminations."
Not Republican. Not Democrat. Not any of the labels sold to us since.
American. Neighbor.
Bound together by fraternal affection. That's not naive. It's the oldest instruction we have…and the one every retention plan depends on us forgetting.
Talk to your neighbors. Especially the ones you were told to fear.
This was the final part of The Politics of Balkanization. Thanks for reading all five. Now go do the homework.
Sources
- TIME, "Read Hillary Clinton's 'Basket of Deplorables' Remarks About Donald Trump Supporters," Sept. 10, 2016: https://time.com/4486502/hillary-clinton-basket-of-deplorables-transcript/
- CNN, "Trump suggests using military against 'enemy from within' on Election Day," Oct. 13, 2024: https://www.cnn.com/2024/10/13/politics/trump-military-enemy-from-within-election-day
- Pew Research Center, "As Partisan Hostility Grows, Signs of Frustration With the Two-Party System," Aug. 9, 2022: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2022/08/09/as-partisan-hostility-grows-signs-of-frustration-with-the-two-party-system/
- Pew Research Center, "Republicans and Democrats increasingly critical of people in the opposing party," Aug. 9, 2022: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2022/08/09/republicans-and-democrats-increasingly-critical-of-people-in-the-opposing-party/
- University of Cambridge, "Slamming political rivals may be the most effective way to go viral," on Rathje, Van Bavel & van der Linden, "Out-group animosity drives engagement on social media," PNAS, June 2021: https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/viralpolitics
- Voelkel et al., "Megastudy testing 25 treatments to reduce antidemocratic attitudes and partisan animosity," Science, Oct. 18, 2024, abstract (PubMed): https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39418366/ ; article DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adh4764
- George Washington, Farewell Address, 1796 (U.S. Senate): https://www.senate.gov/artandhistory/history/resources/pdf/Washingtons_Farewell_Address.pdf



