← All stories

They Manufacture the Emergency…Paid for With Your Card

The sorted, scared group pays the bills.

The Politics of Balkanization, Part 4 of 5

March 2022. Russia has just invaded Ukraine. A Republican Party email lands in a reporter's inbox. It says a poll found most Democrats would flee the country if the U.S. were invaded. Then it asks:

"So we must ask: Would you fight for your country if it was under attack? Researchers need your response by midnight tonight. If you do not respond in time, we will assume you side with the Democrats who wouldn't fight for America."

September 2022. Same reporter, other party. A Democratic subject line: "We're downright BEGGING you." A text: "Election day is 64 days away and we're getting nervous." Earlier that year, over Joe Biden's name: "This isn't easy for me." A few months later: "I hate to ask" (The Guardian, Oct. 10, 2022).

One sounds like a drill sergeant. The other sounds like a worried relative.

Two parties. Same move.

Something terrible is about to happen. The clock is running. Prove whose side you're on…with your card.

The thesis

In Part 2, we saw why a voter whose identity comes with a party attached is cheap. In Part 3, we saw that cheap voter turned into a safe seat.

Seats are one harvest. Here's the next one.

I'll say it plainly.

The sorted, scared group pays the bills.

A camp that already knows who the enemy is doesn't need to be persuaded. It needs to be alarmed, on a schedule. Every alarm comes with a button. Every button funds the next round of alarms.

That's the power play in this part. They manufacture the emergency…and your card pays for it.

How EXACTLY does that work?

Watch the steps.

Step one: sound the alarm. The subject line has one job: get you to open it. It doesn't have to be true. It has to be urgent.

Step two: make it a loyalty test. Now the question isn't "do you agree with this policy?" It's "are you still one of us?" The Guardian's reporter got a Republican National Committee message on June 30, 2022: "Don't you care? Our records show your Trump Advisory Board membership status is STILL PENDING ACTIVATION!" He had never donated.

Step three: start the clock. Midnight tonight. End of the month. A match that expires.

Step four: keep the address. Whatever you do, you're on the list now. Lists get shared.

This isn't one reporter's bad inbox. Princeton researchers collected 317,366 political emails sent by 3,091 senders from December 2019 through Election Day 2020: candidates, parties and PACs, federal and state. They measured six manipulative tactics. Some were clickbait: urgency, sensationalism, teaser subject lines. Some were outright deception, like a "from" line or a "Re:" faked to look as if you'd already been in a conversation with the campaign.

The finding: "The median active sender used at least one manipulative tactic in 42% of their emails" (Mathur et al., Big Data & Society, Jan. 23, 2023).

Look at what else they found.

About 36,000 emails, 11.5% of the whole collection, promised donation "matching," usually by unnamed backers. Legal experts, the authors note, say that kind of match by a wealthy backer would be unlawful for a political campaign, because of federal contribution limits.

A substantial share warned of an imminent fundraising deadline. Those pleas explain the spikes in email volume at the end of each month, "even though most campaigns file FEC reports quarterly."

About 11,300 emails asked you to fill out a "survey." In a sample of 100, the researchers found 88 led to a page made to look as if you had to donate for your answers to count. A handful, 189 of them, had subject lines like "NOT asking for money." The researchers checked 10 of those. All 10 asked for money.

And your address travels. The researchers signed up with a unique email address for every sender, so they could tell who passed it along. They counted 741 cases of an address being handed to someone else, by 322 senders. Sixteen of those senders had privacy policies claiming they didn't share personal information at all.

That's the machine. Alarm. Loyalty. Clock. List.

Both jerseys run it

Is this a one-party problem? The researchers checked. Across party, the type of sender and the type of race, they found only "minor differences" in how likely senders were to use these tactics. About one active sender in ten used them in more than two-thirds of its emails. Among the top senders in that group, the researchers named the Progressive Turnout Project and the Democratic Conservation Alliance.

The Guardian's reporter found the same thing from both sides in 2022. Republican emails came with subject lines like "Your flight is CANCELED," from a sender labeled "urgent notice." (It was about a dinner with Donald Trump.) Many emails he got with "re:" in the subject line, "seemingly from Democrats in particular," pretended to be replies, though he'd never written to them.

And the testing isn't new. The Princeton team confirmed that 2020 presidential candidates were A/B testing their emails. The Guardian notes that Barack Obama's 2012 campaign would test up to 18 versions of an email before sending it widely, and that email brought in roughly $500 million. Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign asked for money 50 different ways in one month.

Different voices. Same machine.

When "yes" is the default

One case shows how far it can go…and it is not a tie.

April 3, 2021. The New York Times reported that in September 2020, the Trump campaign, short on cash and outspent by Democrats, began setting up online donations to repeat every week until the election. By default. Donors had to find a fine-print disclaimer and uncheck a box to opt out. A second prechecked box, known internally as a "money bomb," doubled the gift.

Stacy Blatt was 63, in hospice care, living on less than $1,000 a month. He gave $500. It was his first political donation ever. In less than 30 days, the campaign had withdrawn $3,000 from his account, and his bank froze it.

In the last two and a half months of 2020, the Trump campaign, the Republican National Committee and their shared accounts issued more than 530,000 refunds worth $64.3 million to online donors. For all of 2020, the Trump operation refunded 10.7% of the money it raised through WinRed. The Biden operation refunded 2.2% of what it raised through ActBlue, the Democrats' equivalent platform (The New York Times, April 3, 2021).

To be fair to the record: a Trump spokesman said only 0.87% of WinRed transactions led to formal credit card disputes. WinRed said it was adopting tactics ActBlue had used years earlier. Biden officials said they rarely used prechecked recurring boxes, except on pages where supporters had been explicitly asked to become repeat donors.

Both parties use the machine. On this measure, in this cycle, one side ran it much harder. I'm not going to round that off to make the scorecard look even.

And the person on the other end was a loyal supporter who believed he was helping his side.

Respect him. Confront the idea that loyalty should be harvested by default.

A better guess about you, not mind control

You've probably heard that campaigns know everything about you and can push your buttons at will.

It's more modest than that…and more ordinary.

In 2023, researchers led by MIT tested it. In a first round with over 23,000 participants, they tried out video ads on two policy issues. Then more than 5,000 people were shown either the best-performing ad, a random ad, or an ad picked for them by a model. Tailoring the ad to one trait, such as party affiliation, could be 70% more effective at shifting policy support than showing everyone the single ad expected to work best overall. Targeting on more traits, such as ideology, age and moral values, added no further benefit (MIT News, June 21, 2023, on Tappin et al., PNAS).

Read that carefully. That 70% is a gain in persuasion over another ad strategy, in a survey experiment, on policy opinions. It is not a 70-point swing in votes, and it doesn't show that any campaign changed an election. The benefit varied a lot from one policy to the other, and shrank in a second setup.

"It's clearly not mind control," said David Rand, one of the authors.

So what does all that data buy? A better guess about which button is yours.

And the researchers' example of that one trait? Party. Once you're sorted, you're easy to aim at.

The wedge is the pitch

In Part 2, we followed the ad money. In 2024, by AdImpact's count, Republicans spent $222 million on anti-trans and LGBTQ ads, and Democrats spent just under $29 million on LGBTQ ads (NPR, Nov. 22, 2024).

Wedges cost money to run. The next cycle's ads have to be paid for by somebody. The email in your inbox is how they find that somebody.

In The Business of Balkanization, we boiled one fundraising letter down to three words: Attack. Belong. Pay. Here it is at the party level.

George Washington saw the shape of it. The spirit of party, he warned, "agitates the community with ill founded jealousies and false alarms, kindles the animosity of one part against another" (Washington's Farewell Address, 1796).

False alarms. In 1796. Before anyone had an inbox.

Why this matters now

Here's what this part shows. And what it doesn't.

It doesn't show that every emergency is fake. Some deadlines are real. Some threats are real. Saying so isn't fear mongering.

It doesn't show that anyone pocketed your donation. These sources are about tactics, not personal profit. If someone wants to allege enrichment, they need the vendor records…not a nasty email.

It doesn't show these tactics work. The Princeton team said its data couldn't measure that directly, though its evidence of A/B testing suggests the senders think they do. And it doesn't show that giving to a campaign is wrong. Giving to people you believe in is part of a free country.

What it does show is the conversion. A sorted camp becomes a list. Fear and loyalty become the subject line. The subject line becomes a payment. And the payment funds the next round of fear.

Both parties have done it. Neither has to persuade you of anything new. They only have to remind you who the enemy is…before midnight.

That's how power piles up. And how it pays for staying put.

Ask yourself

What happens if I don't give tonight?

Can they show me the deadline, the match, and what my money actually pays for?

Who actually gets the money? (You can look it up. Every federal campaign and party committee reports its spending, and the Federal Election Commission lets anyone search it at FEC.gov.)

And if the message has to make me afraid of my neighbors before it asks for my card…what is it really selling?

Talk to your neighbors. Especially the ones you've been paying to be afraid of.


Next: Part 5, "The Enemy Is the Retention Plan." Seats and money are two harvests. The last one is your loyalty…and nobody has to earn it as long as you're afraid of the other side.

Sources