The yard sign came down after Election Day.
The neighbor didn't.
You still share a plow route. You still share the transfer station on Saturday morning. You still share a long Maine winter on the same road.
A frequently discussed topic since the election is how to get along with the neighbor who voted the other way.
That's understandable. The campaign was loud. Some of us are relieved. Some of us are worried. The feeling is real on both sides of the ditch.
But the person next door is still the person next door. This isn't a lecture about how you ought to feel. It's a plain look at how to talk to someone with different political views…starting with the one you already wave to.
The yard sign isn't the whole person
A yard sign is a vote. It isn't a biography.
In a 2019 study, the researchers at More in Common found that Democrats and Republicans each believe about 55% of the other side holds extreme views. The real figure is about 30%. We've walked through those numbers before. The pattern is the same: we imagine almost twice as much extremism as is actually there.
Psychologist Kristin Laurin put it in one sentence this month: "Our perceived polarization far outstrips the actual polarization" (NPR, Nov. 2, 2026).
That's the trap. We see the sign. We fill in the rest. We decide we already know the person…when we've mostly been looking at a cartoon.
Respect the person. Confront the idea. That's Rule #7, and it starts at the end of your own driveway. The neighbor is not the party, and the party is not the neighbor. No group of people is all one way or another (Rule #12). Judging a whole person by one vote is the same trap we'd reject if someone did it to us.
Why we stopped talking over the fence
It isn't only in our heads. The distance is showing up on the street.
Political scientist Betsy Sinclair and her colleagues have found that when people get angry at the other party, they start avoiding those neighbors. Not just skipping the argument. Skipping ordinary favors…like watering the plants when someone goes out of town (The Conversation, March 21, 2025).
The circles got tighter, too. In 2020, the Survey Center on American Life found that 53% of Republicans and 55% of Democrats said their core social network was made up entirely of their own candidate's supporters. When the only people you talk with already agree with you, the cartoon gets easier to believe.
It reaches town halls, too. In a summer 2026 CivicPulse survey of 1,224 local officials, 41% reported substantial negative effects of polarization in their own communities. That was 39% in communities under 50,000 people, and 49% in places over 50,000.
Even the smaller towns are feeling it. That's a reason to talk over the fence…not a reason to stop.
How to talk to someone with different political views
So how do you actually do it? Not in theory. On your road.
Four habits. None of them fancy.
Start with the plow, not the president
Talk about the road before you talk about the White House.
People who live in mixed communities, interviewed by the Center for Media Engagement in 2020, offered the same practical advice: talk about local politics instead of national politics, and focus on policy instead of party.
That's easier here than it sounds. The school budget. The road. The dump hours. The things the neighbor actually votes on at town meeting.
You don't have to pretend the national fight doesn't exist. You just don't have to lead with it. Start with the thing you both have to live with when the meeting adjourns.
Ask, don't aim
Ask to learn, not to win.
That's Rule #2. People know when they're being cross-examined. You know it when someone does it to you, and you don't like it.
UVA professor Rachel Wahl studies how people talk across deep disagreement. She suggests questions like these, word for word: "What worries you most about our country? What gives you the most hope? When did you first start caring about that issue? Have your views on it changed for any reason?" (UVA, Oct. 27, 2026).
One question is enough. Then listen to the answer. The point isn't to trap anybody. It's to find out what you'd miss if you only read the sign.
Go for the layup
Start with something you already agree on.
Rule #4 is plain: find common ground first. Build a little goodwill. Work from there. Don't jump to the hardest thing because it feels like courage. Go for the layups.
This month, NPR sat with two friends who had kept politics off the table for years. One has supported President Trump. The other doesn't like the president. When one of them finally answered a question about Venezuela, her friend said, "I agree with absolutely everything she just said."
They had been bracing for a fight that wasn't there. That's what the layup is for. Find the place you already meet, and let that be true before you pick up the rest.
Know when to put the kettle on
If it gets hot, pour the coffee and call it a day.
The American Psychological Association puts it simply: accept that you may not change the other person's mind, and know when to end the conversation peacefully. Understanding is a good goal. Conversion is a lousy one.
Wahl makes the other half of the point. Nobody is obligated to listen when they feel threatened or dehumanized. You can step away and still wave from the driveway.
Two people, one beverage, no audience. That's usually enough. If it isn't, the friendship is still worth more than the last word.
What if it already went sideways?
Maybe you already had the fight. Maybe the wave from the driveway got shorter, or stopped.
The first step is not a debate. Wahl's advice is to reconnect outside politics, then ask with curiosity. The person is bigger than the argument. Start there.
Bring back the ordinary stuff first. A wave. A comment on the plow. Help with a mailbox that leaned over in the last storm. The point is to be neighbors again, not to reopen the last fight.
We've done this before as a country. After a brutal election, John Adams and Thomas Jefferson stopped writing to each other for about 11 years. They started again in 1812. A year later, on July 15, 1813, Adams wrote: "You and I, ought not to die, before We have explained ourselves to each other" (Founders Online).
They still disagreed. They kept writing anyway. You don't have to wait 11 years. You don't even have to agree. You just have to start.
What this looks like here
Up here in Midcoast Maine, we already share the places that matter.
Town meeting. The transfer station on a Saturday. The church supper. The plow guy who hits your driveway and the next one in the same run. Nobody checks a party registration at the door of a baked-bean supper.
You don't need a new program to bump into someone who voted the other way. You need to treat those ordinary places as the point, not the interruption. In a little Vermont town this fall, neighbors who felt the same gap did the simplest thing: they set a table and showed up. A potluck doesn't fix a country. It starts a conversation.
The pledge is small on purpose.
One neighbor. One real conversation.
FAQ
What do you say to someone with different political views?
Start with something you already share: the road, the school, the weather that won't quit. Then ask one curiosity question, and mean it. "What worries you most about our country?" is a better opening than a point you prepared in the car.
Can you stay friends with someone with different political views?
Yes. Most of us overestimate how extreme the other side is. A 2019 study found we imagine about 55% extremism where the real figure is about 30%. Keep the friendship bigger than the topic, and don't let one vote stand in for a whole person.
How do you disagree without making enemies?
Critique the idea and respect the person (Rule #7). Stick to things you can verify. If it stops being a conversation and starts being a performance, put the kettle on and stop. You can pick it up another day.
Should I look up how my neighbors voted?
You can find precinct maps if you want them. A map can't tell you why someone voted the way they did, and it won't tell you what kind of neighbor they are. Ask them over coffee instead.
The sign may go up again next time. The neighbor will still be there. So will you.
This week, have one real conversation with one neighbor.
#TalkToYourNeighbors
Principles at play: Rule #2, Rule #4, Rule #7, Rule #10, Rule #12.



