← All stories

The Lines Were Here Before the Labels

There is no room in this country for hyphenated Americanism.

The Politics of Balkanization, Part 1 of 5

October 12, 1915. Carnegie Hall, New York. Former President Theodore Roosevelt, a Republican, stands before the Knights of Columbus and draws a line.

"There is no room in this country for hyphenated Americanism."

Then he goes further. "The one absolutely certain way of bringing this nation to ruin…would be to permit it to become a tangle of squabbling nationalities." And: "those hyphenated Americans who terrorize American politicians by threats of the foreign vote are engaged in treason to the American Republic" (Roosevelt, "Americanism," Project Gutenberg).

Notice who he says is being terrorized. American politicians. By a vote.

A century later, the hyphen is everywhere. On census forms. In campaign ads. In the names of outreach programs run by both parties.

How did we get from there to here? And who gained power along the way? This series is about how it happens.

The thesis

I'll say it plainly.

Both parties have learned that power is easier to win and easier to keep when the country is divided first…and the voters are divided second.

Divide the populace. Then divide who votes for you.

That isn't a Democrat problem. It isn't a Republican problem. It's a power problem. And the people who warned us about it were looking at it long before anyone said "red state" or "blue state."

In The Business of Balkanization, we followed the money: how the media sells your anger. This series follows the power: how politicians harvest it.

But first, the raw material. Because the lines were here before the labels.

They saw it coming

November 23, 1787. James Madison, in Federalist No. 10, writes that "the latent causes of faction are thus sown in the nature of man." He didn't think you could remove those causes without destroying liberty. So he argued for "controlling its effects" (Federalist No. 10, Library of Congress).

Translation: people will always form groups. The danger is when a group gets to run the rest of us.

Nine years later, George Washington's Farewell Address gets more specific. He warns that "designing men" may try to convince Americans of "a real difference of local interests and views." Then he names the play:

"One of the expedients of party to acquire influence within particular districts is to misrepresent the opinions and aims of other districts."

And the result? "They tend to render alien to each other those who ought to be bound together by fraternal affection" (Washington's Farewell Address, U.S. Senate).

Acquire influence. By misrepresenting your neighbors.

Washington went further. "The alternate domination of one faction over another, sharpened by the spirit of revenge…is itself a frightful despotism."

Alternate domination. Your side wins, then their side wins, and each round settles a score. Sound familiar?

That was 1796.

How EXACTLY does that work?

Here's the pattern. Watch it repeat.

Step one: a line exists. Religion. Region. Ancestry. Race. Sometimes it's real difference. Sometimes it's mostly fear.

Step two: someone sharpens it. The line becomes a threat. "Those people" become a danger to "us."

Step three: someone harvests it. A party, a movement, a politician builds a coalition on the fear…or on the protection from it.

Not every line is a trick. Not every coalition is a con. Some of these coalitions were built to tear the lines down. That distinction matters, and we'll keep it.

But step three is where power lives. Let's look at the record.

1856: Both sides shop for the immigrant vote

By 1856 the American Party…nicknamed the "Know-Nothing Party" because members denied knowing anything about it…had become a national force committed to halting immigration. Its members especially opposed Irish Catholic immigrants, whose loyalty to the Pope, they believed, ruled out loyalty to the United States.

Then the coalitions moved. The Whigs had ceased to exist. The new Republican Party, born in the fight over slavery's expansion, picked up Know-Nothings, in part because it also took an anti-immigrant stance. Meanwhile, "the Democrats courted the Catholic immigrant vote" (OpenStax, U.S. History, 14.2).

Read that again.

One party collected the people afraid of the newcomers. The other collected the newcomers. Same line. Two harvests.

To be fair: the Republican Party's founding cause, stopping slavery's spread, was a moral fight, not a marketing campaign. Opposing slavery is not the same as defending it. But even a righteous coalition took votes where fear made them available.

1882: The line becomes law

May 6, 1882. Congress passed, and Republican President Chester A. Arthur signed, the Chinese Exclusion Act. It barred Chinese laborers from immigrating for ten years. The National Archives calls it the first time "federal law proscribed entry of an ethnic working group on the premise that it endangered the good order of certain localities."

It also barred courts from granting citizenship to Chinese residents already here. It was extended in 1892, made permanent in 1902, and not repealed until 1943…when China was our ally in World War II (National Archives).

Notice the frame. Not "we don't like them." Good order. Public safety. The threat frame.

And notice who paid. Not the politicians. The neighbors who couldn't become citizens for 61 years.

1942: The security frame, the other party

February 19, 1942. Democratic President Franklin Roosevelt issued Executive Order 9066. The order never named an ethnic group. It didn't need to. Military commanders used it to remove and incarcerate Japanese Americans from the West Coast…citizens and immigrants alike.

The National Archives describes how it got there: fear after Pearl Harbor, "economic competition, distrust over cultural separateness, and long-standing anti-Asian racism." And this: "Lobbyists from western states, many representing competing economic interests or nativist groups, pressured Congress and the President" (National Archives).

Competing economic interests. Fear did the public work. Interests did the lobbying.

In 1988, Congress formally acknowledged the injustice, apologized, and paid $20,000 to each person who had been incarcerated.

Sixty years apart. A Republican signed one. A Democrat signed the other. Same play: name a group as a danger, and let the people who benefit stay in the background.

1964: When power had to cross the line

Now the counterexample. Because it matters.

July 2, 1964. President Lyndon Johnson signed the Civil Rights Act. Getting it there wasn't easy. In the Senate, Southern Democratic opponents "attempted to talk the bill to death in a filibuster." The filibuster was broken by Democrat Hubert Humphrey's floor leadership, Johnson's support, and Republican Minority Leader Everett Dirksen, "who convinced enough Republicans to support the bill over Democratic opposition." Final Senate vote: 73 to 27 (National Archives).

Read it straight. No party gets a purified past here. Democrats led the bill. Democrats led the filibuster. Republicans supplied the votes that broke it.

And here's the point for this series: the one time in this story a line got erased by law, it took people from both parties willing to work against members of their own coalition.

Dividing is cheap for a politician. Crossing costs more.

The hyphen: from treason to targeting

Back to Roosevelt. Read him fairly. He said he did not mean naturalized citizens: "Some of the very best Americans I have ever known were naturalized Americans." And he said the rule applied equally to "the man who puts 'native' before the hyphen." His target was divided loyalty, not ancestry.

But the word stuck as a weapon. And the other party picked it up too.

September 25, 1919. Pueblo, Colorado. Democratic President Woodrow Wilson is selling the League of Nations. He says opposition is coming from "certain bodies of sympathy with foreign nations." Then:

"Any man who carries a hyphen about with him carries a dagger that he is ready to plunge into the vitals of this Republic whenever he gets ready. If I can catch any man with a hyphen in this great contest I will know that I have got an enemy of the Republic" (American Presidency Project).

Read that again. Disagree with the President's treaty, and your hyphen becomes evidence against you.

A Republican, then a Democrat. One line. Used to win an argument.

Then the hyphen flipped. By the 1960s and '70s, the pressure to shed your heritage was giving way to pride in it. According to a 1979 history of the federal program it produced, the push for government support of ethnicity "has its roots in the black consciousness and social revolutions of the 1960's." On June 23, 1972, Republican President Richard Nixon signed the Ethnic Heritage Studies Program into law. No money came until 1974 (ERIC, ED184964).

Same era, Republicans went shopping. On May 22, 1971, Bob Dole addressed the Republican Heritage Group Nationalities Council…"the first permanent auxiliary of its kind in the Republican Party." His words: the heritage groups could contribute to the party "if the human resources they embody can be appealed to and channeled properly" (Dole Archives, University of Kansas).

Appealed to. And channeled.

A 2025 study of Nixon's 1972 campaign describes urban, working-class Catholics who had mostly voted Democratic, and says "the majority of them defected to the Republican Party" that year. It credits the work of László Pásztor, director of the GOP's Heritage Groups (Nationalities) Division, with strongly contributing to the result (Hungarian Cultural Studies).

Then government drew the boxes. In 1977, the Office of Management and Budget created Statistical Policy Directive No. 15, the federal standard for race and ethnicity data. OMB says its development "stemmed in large part from new Federal responsibilities to enforce civil rights laws" (Federal Register, March 29, 2024). That's a legitimate purpose. You can't enforce anti-discrimination law if you can't count.

The Census followed. An experimental Hispanic origin question appeared on part of the 1970 census forms. Starting in 1980, the full census asked about Hispanic origin as a separate question. In 2000, Americans could check more than one race for the first time (Pew Research Center). In 1997, OMB split "Asian or Pacific Islander" in two and renamed "Hispanic" to "Hispanic or Latino" (Federal Register, Oct. 30, 1997). In 2024, it added "Middle Eastern or North African" and merged race and ethnicity into one question.

Boxes built to protect people. Boxes that also make people easy to find.

Then the names changed. December 1988, Chicago. After a meeting of about 70 Black leaders, Jesse Jackson said: "To be called African American has cultural integrity." Other groups, he said, "connect their heritage to their mother country," with "a degree of accepted and reasonable pride" (UPI, Dec. 20, 1988).

That's self-description. A group naming itself, with pride, on the same terms as Irish or Italian Americans. Nothing about it is divisive.

Then the fight. In the early 1990s, historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr. published The Disuniting of America. He warned against a "cult of ethnicity" and asked: "When does the obsession with difference begin to threaten the idea of an overarching American nationality?" One critic answered that the book slid into "a nostalgic call for ethnic assimilation to traditional American values" (Bruce Goebel review, Montana State University).

Both had a point. That's why it's still a fight.

And now, the harvest. In October 2020, the Democratic National Committee ran AAPI-targeted ads in Chinese, Hindi, Korean, Telugu, Urdu and Vietnamese (DNC). In March 2024, the Biden campaign launched "Latinos con Biden." That June, the Trump campaign renamed "Latinos for Trump" to "Latino Americans for Trump." Its spokesman's reason: "no matter where we're coming from, we're already American" (NBC News, June 6, 2024).

Speaking someone's language isn't a sin. Reaching people where they are is what campaigns do.

But watch the pattern. First the hyphen meant disloyalty. Then it meant pride. Then it became a target…a box on a form, a language on an ad, a message for each one.

Pride belongs to the people who feel it. The target belongs to whoever is aiming.

The modern sort

Fast forward. In 1994, 10% of Americans held consistently liberal or consistently conservative views on Pew's ten-question scale. By 2014: 21%. Overlap between the parties shrank. By 2014, 92% of Republicans were to the right of the median Democrat, and 94% of Democrats to the left of the median Republican (Pew Research Center, June 12, 2014).

But here's the part both teams should sit with. Pew found most Americans did not hold uniformly liberal or conservative views. Most did not see either party as a threat to the nation. And more wanted their representatives to meet halfway than to hold out for more.

So who's driving? Pew again: "the most ideologically oriented and politically rancorous Americans make their voices heard through greater participation in every stage of the political process." Among politically engaged Democrats, consistent liberals went from 8% to 38%. Among engaged Republicans, consistent conservatives went from 23% to 33%.

The middle hung back. The edges showed up.

And if you're a politician, who do you answer to? The people who show up.

Why this matters now

Here's what the history shows. And what it doesn't.

It doesn't show one party invented division. It doesn't show every group is a scheme. People organize around faith, ancestry and shared struggle for good reasons…often because someone else drew a line around them first.

What it does show: the lines came first. The power came after. And both parties, in different eras, have been willing to sharpen a line when it delivered votes.

Madison saw it. Washington named it. Roosevelt and Wilson both swung the hyphen as a weapon.

The hyphen was never the problem. What politicians do with it is.

And they're always looking for the next one. A new line. A new hyphen. A new group to be afraid of…or a new group that should be afraid. Then they step forward as its champion, for it or against it. Either way, the power goes to the one holding the line.

Ask yourself

Next time a politician tells you about "those people," ask three things:

Was this line drawn around them, or chosen by them?

Who gains power if I'm afraid of them?

And would I accept this argument if the other party were making it about me?

Talk to your neighbors. Especially the ones on the other side of the line.


Next: Part 2, "Make the Group Your Whole World." The lines didn't stop at race and religion. Now they run through sexuality, identity…even our kids. How do organizers on the left and the right persuade you to live inside them…and who benefits when you do?

Sources