May 22, 2020. Joe Biden is wrapping up an interview on "The Breakfast Club." The host says he has more questions. Biden answers:
"If you have a problem figuring out whether you're for me or Trump, then you ain't black" (NBC News, May 22, 2020).
Hours later he apologized. "No one should have to vote for any party, based on their race or religion or background," he said.
March 18, 2024. Donald Trump is talking with Sebastian Gorka.
"Any Jewish person that votes for Democrats hates their religion, they hate everything about Israel, and they should be ashamed of themselves because Israel will be destroyed" (JTA, March 18, 2024). As president in 2019, he'd said Jewish Democratic voters showed "either a total lack of knowledge or great disloyalty."
Two men. Two parties. Same move.
Your identity has a correct vote. Cast the wrong one, and you're not really one of us.
The thesis
In Part 1, we saw that the lines were here before the labels. Parties didn't invent the groups. They harvested them.
But a harvest needs a reliable crop.
A voter who weighs every candidate on the merits is expensive. You have to earn that vote every two years. A voter whose identity comes with a party attached is cheap.
Read that again. A voter whose identity comes with a party attached is CHEAP.
You only have to remind them who they are…and who the enemy is.
That's the power play in this part. Don't just find the group. Make the group your whole world. Then make the party the group's only home.
Belonging is not the problem
Let's be clear about this up front, because it matters.
People organize around who they are for good reasons. Often because someone else drew a line around them first.
April 1977. A group of Black feminists in Boston, the Combahee River Collective, put it plainly: "We believe that the most profound and potentially most radical politics come directly out of our own identity." They called it "identity politics."
Read the rest of it, though. The same authors wrote that they "do not advocate the fractionalization that white women who are separatists demand." They rejected lesbian separatism because "it leaves out far too much and far too many people." They described doing political work "in coalition with other progressive organizations and movements." And this: "we do not want to mess over people in the name of politics" (Gilder Lehrman Institute).
Organize from who you are. Then build bridges.
That's not balkanization. That's community. The question is what happens when someone else picks up the group and starts steering it.
How EXACTLY does that work?
Watch the steps.
Step one: speak to the group. Nothing wrong with that. Campaigns should meet people where they are.
Step two: speak as the group's protector. Now the message is "they're coming for you, and we're the only ones standing in the way."
Step three: make the vote part of the identity. Now leaving the party feels like leaving your people.
Both parties run all three steps. Let's look.
Both parties build the channels
October 11, 2024. The Democratic National Committee announced "a historic, six-figure paid media campaign targeting LGBTQ+ voters in battleground states," which it said would reach "over one million voters in the first week alone." DNC Chair Jaime Harrison called the community "a large and diverse voting bloc that we are not taking for granted" (DNC).
June 2024. The Trump campaign renamed "Latinos for Trump" as "Latino Americans for Trump." The RNC's Hispanic communications director, Jaime Florez, explained: "no matter where we're coming from, we're already American." The same NBC report noted the Biden campaign had launched "Latinos con Biden" that March (NBC News, June 6, 2024).
Notice the difference in wording. One says "voting bloc." The other says "we're already American." That second framing is a real attempt at a bridge, and it deserves credit.
But notice the sameness too. Both built a channel to a group. Both are built to deliver votes.
Then a newer line got drawn.
In 2004, the line was one question. Marriage. A Republican president called for a constitutional ban, and bans passed in all 11 states that voted on one. A Democratic president had signed the Defense of Marriage Act, and the next Democratic president didn't back same-sex marriage until 2012.
Here's what bothers me most. The 14th Amendment promises every person "the equal protection of the laws." In 2015, the Supreme Court said that covers marriage. The Chief Justice dissented: the Constitution "had nothing to do with it."
I believe it had everything to do with it. If both parties…and the courts…had applied equal protection faithfully, marriage would never have spent eleven years as a ballot wedge.
But a settled question doesn't turn out voters. So the lines multiplied. Sports. Bathrooms. Pronouns. Minors' medical care. Curriculum. A new hyphenate…and a new set of champions.
I've watched it up close. My daughter's school here in Maine was ready to accommodate a litter box…until someone raised it as a tripping and sanitation hazard. I don't blame the kid. Kids try things on.
I blame the adults. The ones who were supposed to be the grown-ups in the room…and saw more to gain from sorting children into groups. Assign a child to a group, and you can assign that group a champion. A champion needs a cause, a crowd, and a vote.
Kids need adults. Not advocates looking for a constituency.
Kids can't buy a drink or a cigarette until they're 21. In Maine, they can't get a tattoo until 18…even with a parent's okay. So why would we let a child be treated as an animal? Or take medical steps that can permanently change a healthy body? England's Cass Review called the evidence behind youth gender medicine "remarkably weak." Britain, Sweden, Finland, Norway, Denmark and France's medical academy have moved toward caution.
How many gay or lesbian boys and girls have been permanently harmed because adults weren't the adults in the room? Nobody has a reliable number. That alone should stop us.
And both sides went shopping. In 2024, AdImpact counted $222 million in Republican anti-trans and LGBTQ ads. Democrats spent just under $29 million on LGBTQ ads, and the Human Rights Campaign ran a $15 million program to turn out "Equality Voters."
One side sells protection from the group. The other sells protection for it. Either way, the group comes with a party attached.
Then the group becomes a lifestyle
July 16, 2024. The Daily Wire ran a promotion headlined "Save Money. Fight The Left. Vote With Your Wallet."
"You want to fight the Left? You want to hit them where it hurts? Stop spending your money at woke companies." The pitch offered razors "for real men," chocolate billed as "indoctrination-free," and gifts "for like-minded friends and family members" (The Daily Wire).
The left runs the same play from the other direction. In 2016, after the Access Hollywood tape, the #GrabYourWallet boycott took aim at companies tied to the Trump brand. The group's own account says it "demonstrated women's spending power and offered a peaceful, impactful way to protest the Trump administration's serial targeting of women, immigrants, and communities of color." It also claims "over 70 companies severed ties with the Trump brand." Today its homepage promises to help you "flex your economic power in ways that build a more just and caring society" (Grab Your Wallet, About Us; homepage).
One side says hit the woke companies "where it hurts." The other said take your money away from companies tied to the other side's leader. Different targets. Same instruction: let the fight decide where you shop.
We met the business side of this in The Business of Balkanization. Here's the political side. Your shave, your candy, your store and your gifts all become a way of fighting the other team.
The point isn't that buying from people you agree with is wrong. The point is what happens when there's nothing left in your week that isn't part of the fight.
The whole world, by the numbers
How far has this gone? Pew measured it.
In 2014, 63% of consistent conservatives and 49% of consistent liberals said most of their close friends shared their political views. Among Americans with mixed views, just 25% said the same. Half of consistent conservatives (50%) and 35% of consistent liberals said it was important to live in a place where most people share their politics.
It reaches into the family too. Thirty percent of consistent conservatives said they'd be unhappy if an immediate family member married a Democrat. Twenty-three percent of consistent liberals said the same about a Republican in-law (Pew Research Center, June 12, 2014).
The right sorts a bit harder on these measures. The left isn't far behind. And the people in the middle, the ones with mixed views, are the least likely to live in a bubble.
Friends. Neighbors. In-laws. That's what "your whole world" looks like when it's measured.
When belonging becomes a test
Here's where solidarity turns.
Solidarity says: we stand together. A loyalty test says: prove you're one of us…and here's the vote, the slogan, the enemy that proves it.
We live in a world full of purity tests. Almost none of them test principle or character.
They test the jersey.
Biden's line tested Black voters by their ballot. Trump's line tested Jewish voters by their ballot. Neither one asked about anyone's honesty, faith, work, or what kind of neighbor they are.
Some loyalty tests go further, and they decide who counts as American at all. PRRI measures Christian nationalism with five statements, including "Being Christian is an important part of being truly American" and "The U.S. government should declare America a Christian nation." In its February 2026 report, about one in three Americans qualified as Adherents (11%) or Sympathizers (21%). Among Republicans, 21% were Adherents and 35% Sympathizers. Among Democrats, 5% and 12% (PRRI, Feb. 2026).
Be careful with that. It measures views about Christianity, government and national identity, not Christian faith itself. And it's a survey of beliefs, not a finding that any party planted them. But "truly American" is a test of belonging, and every non-Christian neighbor fails it by definition.
When the institution picks a side
Loyalty tests get stronger when the institutions around you all lean the same way.
Start with the pulpit. A 2017 study matched 130,000 clergy to voter files. Reform and Conservative rabbis, Black church pastors and Unitarian ministers were "nearly entirely Democratic." Fundamentalist and Independent Baptist pastors were "nearly all Republican." And pastors were more one-sided than their own flocks: in ELCA Lutheran churches, 46% of members were Democrats, but 73% of pastors (Hersh & Malina).
Follow the money. In the 2024 cycle, by OpenSecrets' count of PAC and employee contributions to federal candidates and parties: teachers unions gave 99% to Democrats, industrial unions 97%, education 92%, TV/movies/music 89%. On the other side: gun rights groups gave 99% to Republicans, coal mining 98%, oil and gas 88%, trucking 87% (teachers unions, industrial unions, education, TV/movies/music, gun rights, coal, oil and gas, trucking). Donors aren't the whole workforce, and union PACs aren't their members. But each institution knows which party it's betting on.
Then the faculty. At 51 top liberal arts colleges, registered Democratic professors outnumbered Republicans 10.4 to 1, and 39% of the colleges had none at all. By field, it ran from 1.6 to 1 in engineering to 108 to 0 in interdisciplinary studies like gender and Africana studies (Langbert, 2018). In history departments at 40 leading universities: 33.5 to 1 (Langbert, Quain & Klein, 2016). Fair caveat: Langbert openly calls this imbalance troubling, and a 2008 study by one Republican and one Democratic professor found "no evidence" that this tilt changed students' views (Inside Higher Ed). The damage shows up elsewhere. Republicans' confidence in higher education fell from 56% in 2015 to 20% in 2024 (Gallup).
So ask yourself: when everyone in the room is on your team, who tells you you're wrong?
Why this pays
Here's the power through-line.
A party that owns a group's identity doesn't have to win that group's vote. It only has to keep the group afraid of the other side and suspicious of anyone who strays.
And the institutions that lean all one way make that easier. Your church, your school, your union, your industry, your favorite brand…each one quietly confirms which side people like you are on.
That's the whole world. That's the trap.
Ask yourself
Can I belong to this community, disagree politically, and still be treated as one of its people?
When someone tells me my identity comes with a correct vote, who benefits?
And when was the last time someone in my circle told me I was wrong…and I listened?
Talk to your neighbors. Especially the ones who were told they don't belong.
Next: Part 3, "They Pick the Voters. Then Guard the Door." Once people are sorted into camps, the political harvest begins…starting with the maps.
Sources
- NBC News, Biden "you ain't black," May 22, 2020: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2020-election/biden-tells-african-americans-you-ain-t-black-if-they-n1212911
- JTA, Trump on Jewish Democratic voters, Mar. 18, 2024: https://www.jta.org/2024/03/18/politics/trump-jews-who-vote-for-democrats-hate-their-religion
- Combahee River Collective Statement, April 1977 (Gilder Lehrman Institute): https://www.gilderlehrman.org/ap-african-american-studies/unit-4/black-power-politics-culture/combahee-river-collective-statement-1977
- DNC, LGBTQ+ ad campaign, Oct. 11, 2024: https://democrats.org/dnc-announces-historic-six-figure-ad-campaign-targeting-over-one-million-lgbtq-voters-in-battleground-states-and-races/
- Bush, call for a marriage amendment, Feb. 24, 2004: https://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2004/02/20040224-2.html
- Pew Research, 2004 marriage-ban ballot results: https://www.pewresearch.org/2006/07/26/wedge-issues-on-the-ballot/
- Clinton Library, Defense of Marriage Act (1996): https://www.clintonlibrary.gov/research/archives/finding-aids/1996-defense-marriage-act-doma
- CNN, Obama backs same-sex marriage, May 9, 2012: https://www.cnn.com/2012/05/09/politics/obama-same-sex-marriage
- Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), majority and dissent: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/14-556
- NPR, AdImpact 2024 totals ($222 million Republican anti-trans/LGBTQ ads; just under $29 million Democratic LGBTQ ads), Nov. 22, 2024: https://www.npr.org/sections/shots-health-news/2024/11/22/nx-s1-5188573/transgender-gender-affirming-care-trump-abortion-hyde-amendment
- NBC News, HRC $15 million 2024 program, May 20, 2024: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2024-election/americas-largest-lgbtq-rights-group-plans-15-million-swing-state-blitz-rcna152383
- National Minimum Drinking Age Act (23 U.S.C. § 158): https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title23-section158
- FDA, Tobacco 21: https://www.fda.gov/tobacco-products/retail-sales-tobacco-products/tobacco-21
- Maine tattooing of minors, 32 M.R.S. § 4203: https://legislature.maine.gov/legis/statutes/32/title32sec4203.html
- Cass Review final report, April 2024 (archived): https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20250310143633/https://cass.independent-review.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/CassReview_Final.pdf
- NHS England, puberty blocker clinical policy, March 2024: https://www.england.nhs.uk/publication/clinical-policy-puberty-suppressing-hormones/
- UK government, puberty blocker restriction made indefinite, Dec. 2024: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/ban-on-puberty-blockers-to-be-made-indefinite-on-experts-advice
- Sweden, Socialstyrelsen guidance: https://www.socialstyrelsen.se/contentassets/444af6c0a5fb429c9b56fd51b931a816/2023-1-8330.pdf
- Finland, COHERE recommendation (2020): https://palveluvalikoima.fi/documents/1237350/22895008/Summary_minors_en.pdf
- Norway, UKOM report (2023): https://ukom.no/rapporter/pasientsikkerhet-for-barn-og-unge-med-kjonnsinkongruens/sammendrag
- Denmark, Ugeskrift for Læger (2023): https://content.ugeskriftet.dk/sites/default/files/2023-06/V11220740_WEB.pdf
- France, National Academy of Medicine (2022): https://www.academie-medecine.fr/la-medecine-face-a-la-transidentite-de-genre-chez-les-enfants-et-les-adolescents/
- NBC News, "Latino Americans for Trump," June 6, 2024: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/latino/latinos-trump-rebrands-launch-latino-americans-trump-rcna155708
- The Daily Wire, "Save Money. Fight The Left. Vote With Your Wallet," July 16, 2024: https://www.dailywire.com/news/save-money-fight-the-left-vote-with-your-wallet
- Grab Your Wallet, About Us and homepage: https://grabyourwallet.org/about-us ; https://grabyourwallet.org/
- Pew Research Center, Political Polarization in the American Public, June 12, 2014: https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2014/06/12/political-polarization-in-the-american-public/
- PRRI, Mapping Christian Nationalism Across the 50 States (2025 American Values Atlas), Feb. 2026: https://prri.org/research/mapping-christian-nationalism-across-the-50-states-insights-from-prris-2025-american-values-atlas/
- Hersh & Malina, "Partisan Pastor," 2017: https://www.eitanhersh.com/uploads/7/9/7/5/7975685/hersh_malina_pastors_june2017.pdf
- OpenSecrets industry pages, 2024 cycle: L1300, P02, W04, B02, Q13, E1210, E01, M03 (URLs inline)
- Langbert, "Homogenous," Academic Questions, 2018: https://academicquestions.org/homogenous-the-political-affiliations-of-elite-liberal-arts-college-faculty/
- Langbert, Quain & Klein, Econ Journal Watch, Sept. 2016: https://econjwatch.org/File+download/944/LangbertQuainKleinSept2016.pdf
- Inside Higher Ed on Mariani & Hewitt (PS, 2008): https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2008/03/27/faculty-are-liberal-who-cares
- Gallup, July 8, 2024: https://news.gallup.com/poll/646880/confidence-higher-education-closer-pre-2023-levels.aspx



